Old Fashioned Whiskey Cocktail

Sylvia Simm | 09. May 2025

An Old Fashioned is the epitome of a classic whiskey cocktail: pure, uncomplicated and a favourite of beginners, connoisseurs and gourmets for over 150 years. On our website, you can find out how to conjure up a perfectly balanced drink in no time at all with just a few carefully selected ingredients - whether bourbon or rye, sugar, bitters and an orange zest.

We shed light on the historical development and give recommendations and tips to make your Old Fashioned cocktail a success.

Table of content

What is an Old Fashioned cocktail?

The Old Fashioned is one of the oldest cocktails and THE oldest cocktail with whisky. It is a so-called "spirit-forward" cocktail in which the whisky takes centre stage. Sugar, bitters and an optional splash of water round off the flavour profile without masking the character of the whisky. An Old Fashioned is pure enjoyment!

History & origin of the Old Fashioned

The Old Fashioned has its origins in the United States. At the beginning of the 18th century, people began mixing drinks with alcohol and the term "cocktail" was mentioned for the first time. At that time, only a few ingredients were added to the spirits and the Old Fashioned was simply called a "whisky cocktail". It was not until the second half of the century that it became customary to add more ingredients to cocktails. However, many people still favoured the simpler versions and called them "Old Fashioned". As the whisky cocktail was usually ordered under this name, it evolved over the years into the Old Fashioned as we know it today.

In 1881, a regular at the "Pendennis Club" in Louisville is said to have demanded: "Give me the old-fashioned cocktail." Since then, the name has been the programme.

Classic Old Fashioned recipe

Ingredients

- 6 cl bourbon whiskey

- 1 cl sugar syrup

- 3 dashes of flavoured bitters

- 1 large or 3 small ice cubes

 

Accessories & glass selection

The exact quantities are measured using a bar measure, the jigger. The ingredients are poured directly into the glass. A small tumbler is suitable here - this glass shape is now known as an old fashioned glass! The cocktail is carefully stirred with a long spoon, the stirrer.

Preparation steps

Handle the ingredients gently. Pour the sugar syrup, bitters and bourbon into a chilled tumbler one after the other. Add the ice and stir the cocktail slowly with a bar spoon. Give the drink some time to develop!

The matching set

A simple orange zest or a cocktail cherry is suitable for decoration.

Whiskey selection for the Old Fashioned H2

Which type of Whiskey is suitable?

Always use a good whiskey for a cocktail where the alcohol is in the foreground! We are happy to recommend the following whiskeys:

  • Maker's Mark is good for beginners with its rich full vanilla flavour.
  • Woodford Reserve Bourbon offers rich vanilla flavours and rye notes.
  • Elijah Craig Small Batch is something special with its soft and spicy notes.

But a rye is also recommended as a whiskey. It brings a spicy, peppery character to the glass.

Which Whiskey is the best?

The "best" whiskey depends on personal taste. For a classic balance, we like to recommend the 1776 Bourbon.

Professional tips for the perfect Old Fashioned

All ingredients can be varied. Sugar cubes instead of sugar syrup or cane sugar for a caramel flavour. The choice of bitters ranges from classic Angostura bitters to orange bitters and chocolate bitters. A few drops of water create new flavours. And of course, different bourbons are also possible!

By the way: Is the flavour too intense for you? You can always add water to the Old Fashioned to soften the sharpness of the alcohol. You can also chill the ingredients beforehand. The cold reduces the vapour pressure of the flavourings, making the taste milder.

Variants and creative variations

Whether classic or in creative variations - this cocktail impressively demonstrates how maximum enjoyment can be achieved with minimum effort.

Smoky Old Fashioned: With peaty scotch instead of bourbon.
Maple Old Fashioned: Maple syrup replaces sugar.
Spiced Old Fashioned: Cinnamon stick and cloves as garnish.

And then there's the New Fashioned: sugar is replaced by honey syrup, which makes it taste very sweet!

Bourbon Whiskey vs. Scotch Single Malts: Which is better for an Old Fashioned?

There is no hard and fast rule - every whisky cocktail is a matter of personal taste. Historically, rye whiskey was used before Prohibition. During Prohibition (1920-1933), the lack of rye led to a switch to sweeter bourbons, and so the bourbon old fashioned became established.

Scotch single malts can also be mixed, but are often favoured neat in the scene. They are considered to be too fine to be altered with sugar and bitters.

Today you decide for yourself:

  • Purist? Then leave the single malt undiluted.
  • Cocktail fan? Bourbon or rye provide classic flavours, while scotch adds smoke and depth.

Try both variants - you'll find your personal Old Fashioned favourite!

A selection of American whiskeys

Maker's Mark Cask Strength 109.5 Proof
Maker's Mark Cask Strength 109.5 Proof
0,7/ l · incl.  VAT
St. Laurent 3 Grains Whisky 3 Years
St. Laurent 3 Grains Whisky 3 Years
0,7/ l · incl.  VAT
Garrison Brothers Small Batch
Garrison Brothers Small Batch
0,7/ l · incl.  VAT
Willett Family Estate Rye 4 Years
Willett Family Estate Rye 4 Years
0,7/ l · incl.  VAT
Daviess County Cabernet Sauvignon Finish
Daviess County Cabernet Sauvignon Finish
0,7/ l · incl.  VAT
Widow Jane Bourbon 10 Years
Widow Jane Bourbon 10 Years
0,7/ l · incl.  VAT
Wild Turkey 101
Wild Turkey 101
0,7/ l · incl.  VAT
F.E.W Black Rebel Motorcycle Club - Motor Oil
F.E.W Black Rebel Motorcycle Club - Motor Oil
0,7/ l · incl.  VAT
Horse Soldier Straight Bourbon
Horse Soldier Straight Bourbon
0,7/ l · incl.  VAT
Ridgemont Reserve 1792 Small Batch
Ridgemont Reserve 1792 Small Batch
0,7/ l · incl.  VAT
Basil Hayden's 1 litre
Basil Hayden's 1 litre
1/ l · incl.  VAT
Brother's Bond Bottled in Bond
Brother's Bond Bottled in Bond
0,7/ l · incl.  VAT

Conclusion

The Old Fashioned combines tradition and purism. With just a few simple steps, a cocktail is created that impresses with the quality of the ingredients and a fine touch. Whether classic or creatively varied - this drink remains timeless.

Experience the flavour of a cocktail legend!

Did you like the article? Then please give us a thumbs up!

This record has been liked 3 times.

Sylvia Simm is an experienced employee of Whisky.de. After more than 20 years in online sales and service, she supports the company with her extensive whisky knowledge in marketing. As online editor and content manager, she is responsible for editing and updating the texts on the knowledge pages.

more

To comment, you must be logged in

Comments (0)